×

Notice

The forum is in read only mode.

Community
Community
Events
Beoir Awards 2012

TOPIC:

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #19

What happens if/when method of dispense matters?

Porterhouse HopHead kicked ash on cask, but bottle or tap wouldn't come close. Ditto Metalman PA on cask; a whole different beer.

Mention that in voting or is this splitting hairs?

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #20

You make your own decision. Consider the vote an average: was the good version of the beer so good that, even taking into consideration the less-good version, it outweighs your enjoyment of another beer you liked? If so, rank it higher.

Statements on dispense are not taken into account in voting, nor on the winners' citations.

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #21

Man Hophead definitely went way up in my estimation from the couple of cask pints I had of it in Against the Grain, superb.

As far as I know the vote is dispense neutral, so you'll just have to weigh up your feelings about the beer.

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #22

yep, I think there is a massive difference between hop head draft vs the bottle.
For me Howling gale is the opposite, far nicer out of the bottle than on draft.

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #23

Can we keep the discussion of individual beers out of this thread?

Beoir Awards 2012 14 years 3 months ago #24

Hey John, my mail got rejected by the spam filter on the Beoir server for some reason, any chance I can do it by PM?
Community
Community
Events
Beoir Awards 2012
Time to create page: 0.169 seconds