Personally I love Homewood, it looks like a Nice town with easy train access to the loop.
Aurora is still a possibility though, pretty much any suburb but Homewood is near south Holland (thornton) where some of her family are. One deciding factor might be what beer I can get. I would love a local that sells craft beer or even a brewpub.
Be a few years till we get to move but if we do, we will have to meet up. Likewise next time we visit Chicago I will let you know.