A friend of mine bought a boat last year and found a bottle of guinness onboard. I think he reckoned it was about 20 years old and said it was awful, but have a go anyway, see what happens.
There's constant reference on here to how Guinness was better in previous generations. I think that this is a definitive way to prove if that's the case or not.
I say buy a pint of modern Guinness and follow it up with the ancient Guinness and if the latter isn't as nice we'll have our answer for once and for all.
"Poc":f3bohvjk wrote: I think that this is a definitive way to prove if that's the case or not.[/quote:f3bohvjk]I think you have to go back before 1960 for that. And preferably to the Great Attenuation Shift[/url:f3bohvjk] of the late 1940s.
Oh, and I think freshness might be a wee bit of an issue as well with this sort of beer.
"TheBeerNut":37grzddr wrote: I think you have to go back before 1960 for that. And preferably to the Great Attenuation Shift[/url:37grzddr] of the late 1940s.
Oh, and I think freshness might be a wee bit of an issue as well with this sort of beer.[/quote:37grzddr]
"Nev":bsoxy4ix wrote: A friend recently unearthed a small bottle of Guinness with a best before date of 1974...there is a fierce temptation there to crack it open & sample it, but obviously the likelihood of it being fit for consumption must be very low...any thoughts??[/quote:bsoxy4ix]
Would it have been bottle-conditioned at that time? <!-- s:?: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_question.gif" alt=":" title="Question" /><!-- s:?: --> If so, I'd wonder about offering it to White Labs or Wyeast to see if they could salvage anything from it...
&quot;Les_Howarth&quot;:1wk8weot wrote: Would it have been bottle-conditioned at that time? <!-- s:?: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_question.gif" alt=":" title="Question" /><!-- s:?: --> If so, I'd wonder about offering it to White Labs or Wyeast to see if they could salvage anything from it...[/quote:1wk8weot]As far as I know, Guinness was bottle conditioned until about 2000. I'm told by a veteran Irish homebrewer that harvesting Guinness yeast was standard practice until then.